Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage (September 2026)
Updated September 7, 2026 · Data from WordPress.org, refreshed daily · How this works
Both rank in the WordPress.org 404 Error Plugins top 10: Smart Custom 404 Error Page at #1 and All 404 Redirect to Homepage at #2. Smart Custom 404 Error Page leads on 3 of the 5 measures we track. Every number below comes straight from WordPress.org and is refreshed every day.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page
Create a custom 404 error page the easy way! No coding, and no redirects.
All 404 Redirect to Homepage
Using this plugin, you can fix all 404 error links by redirecting them to homepage using the SEO 301 redirection. Improve your SEO rank & pages speed
Who leads on what
Smart Custom 404 Error Page leads on 3 of the 5 measures we track.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page ranks higher on WordPress.org: #1 against #2 in 404 Error Plugins.
All 404 Redirect to Homepage has more users: 200,000+ active installs against 100,000+.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page is rated higher: 4.9 out of 5 from 1,196 reviews, against 4.1 from 96 reviews.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page has more reviews behind its score: 1,196 against 96.
All 404 Redirect to Homepage was updated more recently, on August 21, 2026; Smart Custom 404 Error Page on May 21, 2026.
Which one to pick
Each plugin is the better answer for the measure it actually leads on. Nothing here is a recommendation we invented.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page
Pick Smart Custom 404 Error Page if you go by where WordPress.org itself puts them, the review score matters most to you or you want the score backed by more reviews.
All 404 Redirect to Homepage
Pick All 404 Redirect to Homepage if you want the plugin more sites already run or you want the one shipping releases most recently.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage side by side
| Smart Custom 404 Error Page | All 404 Redirect to Homepage | |
|---|---|---|
| 404 Error Plugins ranking | #1 | #2 |
| Rating | 4.9 | 4.1 |
| Reviews | 1,196 | 96 |
| Active installs | 100,000+ | 200,000+ |
| Total downloads | 2,737,803 | 6,223,968 |
| Downloads, last 30 days | – | – |
| Last updated | May 21, 2026 | Aug 21, 2026 |
| First published | Sep 30, 2013 | Mar 19, 2014 |
| Tested up to WordPress | 7.0.4 | 6.9.7 |
| Requires PHP | 5.4 | – |
| Pricing | Free on WordPress.org | Free on WordPress.org |
30-day download figures appear after both plugins have 30 days of tracking.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page ratings
All 404 Redirect to Homepage ratings
How we compare these two
Every figure here is pulled from the WordPress.org plugin API every day at 03:00 UTC, for both plugins in the same run, so the two are always read on the same day. We compare only what the directory reports: active installs, the rating and how many reviews stand behind it, the last release date and, once we have a month of history, downloads over the last 30 days. Ratings are only called a win above 50 reviews each, because a handful of five-star reviews is not evidence. Nothing is weighted into an overall score, no measure is worth more than another, and neither Smart Custom 404 Error Page nor All 404 Redirect to Homepage can pay to appear here: the pair exists only because both plugins reached the 404 Error Plugins top 10. Full methodology.
Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage: common questions
Is Smart Custom 404 Error Page better than All 404 Redirect to Homepage?
Smart Custom 404 Error Page leads on 3 of the 5 measures we track. Neither is better at everything, and the answer depends on which measure you weigh. Smart Custom 404 Error Page ranks higher on WordPress.org: #1 against #2 in 404 Error Plugins.
Which has more users, Smart Custom 404 Error Page or All 404 Redirect to Homepage?
Smart Custom 404 Error Page ranks higher on WordPress.org: #1 against #2 in 404 Error Plugins.
Which is rated higher, Smart Custom 404 Error Page or All 404 Redirect to Homepage?
All 404 Redirect to Homepage has more users: 200,000+ active installs against 100,000+.
Are Smart Custom 404 Error Page and All 404 Redirect to Homepage free?
Both are free to install from WordPress.org. Smart Custom 404 Error Page may also sell a paid version or add-ons. All 404 Redirect to Homepage may also sell a paid version or add-ons.
Alternatives to Smart Custom 404 Error Page and All 404 Redirect to Homepage
Plugins that score close to both in the same WordPress.org rankings and tags.
-
Redirect 404 to Homepage
60,000+ installs · 4.6 from 23 reviews
-
Redirection
2 million+ installs · 4.4 from 703 reviews
-
Redirect 404 Error Page to Homepage or Custom Page
10,000+ installs · 5.0 from 45 reviews
-
Custom URL
4,000+ installs · 5.0 from 2 reviews
-
301 Redirects
30,000+ installs · 4.6 from 28 reviews
More 404 Error Plugins comparisons
- 301 Redirects vs Smart Custom 404 Error Page
- 301 Redirects vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage
- 404 Solution vs Smart Custom 404 Error Page
- 404 Solution vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage
- Redirect 404 to Homepage vs Smart Custom 404 Error Page
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Colorlib 404 Customizer
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Custom 404 Error Page
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Custom 404 Pro
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Redirect 404 Error Page to Homepage or Custom Page
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Custom URL
- Smart Custom 404 Error Page vs Redirection
- All 404 Redirect to Homepage vs Colorlib 404 Customizer
Weekly · free
What moved this week
One email a week, built from the same daily snapshots these rankings come from: the plugins that climbed, what launched, and one ranking worth a look.